Researcher Dismisses Welfare Claims by One Nation Candidate as ‘Completely Wrong’

3 min read
A leading Australian social policy researcher has strongly rejected claims made by New South Wales One Nation upper house candidate Katherine Deves about welfare dependency among migrant communities, describing the figures cited by the candidate as “very misleading” and “completely wrong.”

The controversy emerged after Deves, a lawyer and former Liberal Party candidate, argued that high rates of welfare use among some migrant groups were a reason to significantly reduce immigration to Australia. Speaking on ABC Radio Sydney, she claimed that welfare dependence among certain migrant communities was substantially higher than among the broader Australian population.

Following the interview, One Nation identified a graph posted by Deves on social media as the source of the claims. The chart purported to show welfare participation rates among working-age Australians based on country of birth, excluding recipients of the age pension.

According to the graph, people born in countries including Sudan, Iraq and Syria had some of the highest rates of welfare use in Australia. The data was reportedly based on information from the Department of Social Services and the Australian Bureau of Statistics, although the methodology used to produce the figures was not explained.

However, Professor Peter Whiteford, Director of the Social Policy Institute at the Australian National University, said the chart’s figures did not accurately reflect available evidence. He described many of the numbers as puzzling and argued that the data presented was significantly flawed.

Whiteford explained that migrants from countries such as Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan often include large numbers of humanitarian entrants and refugees, who are generally eligible for government support upon arrival. This, he said, helps explain why some groups may have higher rates of social security payments.

At the same time, he noted that migrants from countries such as India and China typically record lower rates of welfare dependency than Australian-born residents, highlighting the diversity of migrant experiences in Australia.

The debate over migration and welfare comes as political parties continue to outline their positions ahead of upcoming elections, with immigration remaining a prominent issue in public discussions.

The controversy also drew attention to comments made by another One Nation candidate, Stuart Bonds, who recently stated at an anti-immigration rally that white Australians were being “demographically replaced.” The remarks were widely criticized by political leaders and commentators, who linked them to the discredited “Great Replacement” conspiracy theory.

As debate continues over migration policy, economists and social policy experts have stressed the importance of relying on accurate data and context when discussing welfare use, workforce participation and population growth.

You May Also Like

More From Author

+ There are no comments

Add yours